To hear more about the law and our services, please contact us. We also welcome your comments, questions, and suggestions for topics you want to learn about, so please share those too.
Landlord’s Guide to Pets, Service, and Companion Animals
BanCal Property Management • September 3, 2021
Avoid Fair Housing Mistakes with Your Rental Home
Pets, service animals, and companion animals all have to be treated differently by landlords and San Francisco property managers. It’s been a pretty hot topic lately, and that’s because the definition of a service or companion animal seems to be expanded. If you have a tenant who has tried to move in with an emotional support snake, you know what we mean.
It’s easy to make a fair housing mistake when it comes to classifying and verifying these animals. If you try to charge pet rent on an emotional support animal or you reject a tenant who needs a Seeing Eye Dog, you could find yourself in a lot of legal trouble.
Here’s how we’re parsing the discussion for purposes of your San Francisco rental property:
- Pets and whether you should accept them
- Service animals and what they are
- Companion animals, which include emotional support animals and therapy animals
You need to know the difference and the particularities if you want to avoid potentially expensive conflicts and disputes.
WHEN IS A DOG NOT A PET?
The answer is this: when it’s a service animal. A good pet policy is essential in a rental property, but you have to remember that your pet policy does not apply to service and companion animals.
1. PET-FRIENDLY PROPERTIES MAKE FINANCIAL SENSE FOR INVESTORS AND OWNERS
You won’t find any laws on the local or federal level that instruct landlords to allow pets into their rental properties. You can say no pets and be done with it. However, we recommend that you consider allowing pets because we’ve found that pet-friendly properties rent faster. You can typically earn more money on pet rent and pet fees. Tenants with pets tend to stay longer too, because they don’t want to find another pet-friendly property and pay another pet deposit.
A solid pet policy and good property management will protect your property against the risk that comes with allowing pets. However, you don’t have to allow pets if you don’t want to.
The rules aren’t the same when we talk about service and companion animals.
2. GET TO KNOW THE FAIR HOUSING ACT AND THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT
Service and companion animals are governed by two specific federal laws: the Fair Housing Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Both of these laws protect people with physical, emotional, and intellectual disabilities against discrimination, including discrimination that may occur when they’re looking for housing. According to these laws, you cannot deny a tenant the use of a service animal or a companion animal, which is most frequently an emotional support animal or a therapy animal.
As a landlord, you must allow those animals because they are accommodations, not pets. The law sees them the same way they see wheelchairs or braille signs or ramps.
When you allow pets in your property, you can charge a pet deposit or a pet fee. You can also charge extra rent every month and call it pet rent.
However, these additional charges are not permitted when your tenant has a service or companion animal.
3. SERVICE ANIMAL OR COMPANION ANIMAL? THERE’S A DIFFERENCE
Service animals are trained to help a person do a specific task. When a
San Francisco tenant needs a service animal for a physical or intellectual disability, it’s usually obvious what that animal is needed for, and therefore you can’t ask for details or specifics. You wouldn’t ask a person with a vision impediment why they need a Seeing Eye Dog. It’s inferred.
However, companion animals are not trained or certified in any way. They do support and comfort the person who owns them, and they’re acquired at the direction of a healthcare professional. You can ask for documentation if the disability is not immediately apparent and your tenant is requesting an emotional support animal or a companion animal.
What does this mean for your rental property?
Well, the bottom line is this: You don’t have to allow pets, but you should. You do have to allow service animals and companion animals because they are not considered pets - they’re accommodations.
SAN FRANCISCO PROPERTY MANAGEMENT CAN KEEP YOU COMPLIANT
If you’re worried about making what could potentially be a very expensive mistake, we understand. At BanCal Property Management, we’ve been protecting investments like yours since 1987. We keep up to date on all the laws and regulations pertaining to your property and things like pets and service animals.
When deciding to invest in San Francisco real estate, you'll want our best tips and tricks! Make sure to always check...
Deciding to invest in San Francisco real estate can be a big decision. Make it easier by using BanCal Properties' expertise to your advantage!
At BanCal, we understand that trusted vendors are essential to maintaining high-quality properties. That’s why we follow a thorough and intentional vendor screening process to ensure every contractor and service provider meets the standards our residents and property owners expect.
At BanCal, one of the most important parts of our property management approach is conducting a thorough annual walkthrough of every unit we oversee. These yearly check-ins allow us to closely examine each space, identify potential issues early, and ensure your property is being properly maintained. We take our time during these walkthroughs. Each unit receives a detailed, hands-on review focused on small but important details that may go unnoticed or unreported by tenants. During the visit, we check for: Functioning smoke and carbon monoxide detectors Leaks or plumbing issues in faucets, toilets, and under sinks Signs of wear and tear, mildew, or water damage Window seals and anything that may affect heating, airflow, or insulation These visits help confirm that the unit remains safe and habitable. They also present opportunities to catch minor maintenance issues before they become costly repairs. For example, a slow leak or a running toilet can quietly increase water bills over time. Why do we take this approach? Because tenants don’t always report problems—sometimes they overlook them, or simply don’t realize an issue needs attention. A yearly walkthrough gives us valuable insight into the true condition of the unit. In addition to these interior reviews, our team also inspects the exterior of your property at least once a month. We check landscaping, look for visible wear, and flag anything that may need attention. After the annual walkthrough, we’ll provide you with a full report that includes photos, detailed notes, and recommended next steps based on our findings. While not a formal inspection, our reports are grounded in years of experience and a trained eye for detail—so you always know what’s going on with your property. These annual check-ins are a key part of how we protect your investment, promote tenant satisfaction, and maintain the long-term value of your property. At BanCal , we treat every property like it’s our own—and that’s why this process matters.
